Liberal and Orthodox Jewish Responses to Antisemitism and Assimilationism in the United States during the 1920s: Rabbis Mordecai Kaplan’s and Bernard Revel’s Reconstruction of Judaism for the New American Realities
Pages 679 - 701
This publication is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons License Attribution - NonCommercial - NoDerivatives 4.0.
By the 1920s, American Judaism was at a crossroads. After decades of Jewish mass migration into the United States, restrictive immigration laws brought the Jewish community to a crisis. Here was a widespread belief that as the number of Jewish immigrants was sharply reduced, the American Jewish community would not withstand the forces of assimilation for long. There were two American rabbis, both Eastern European immigrants, whose responses to this situation proved to be especially remarkable. Liberal rabbi Mordecai M. Kaplan envisioned the re-interpretation of Jewish tradition in terms of modern thought, fostering the social solidarity of the Jewish people and the formulation of a code of Jewish practice so that every Jew may know what constitutes loyalty to Judaism. In comparison, Orthodox rabbi Bernard Revel sought to build up an educational system for religiously observant American Jewry in which they would not feel alienated and get lost through assimilation and, yet, still receive a secular education. This paper will present and compare the arguments of Kaplan and Revel, primarily focusing on their writings. Although the two rabbis saw similar challenges facing the community, they proposed different reforms of Jewish communal life that both still influence the American Jewish landscape today.
1 Beker, Avi. The Chosen: The History of an Idea, the Anatomy of an Obsession. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008. Print.
2 Berger, Alan L. Children of Job: American Second-Generation Witnesses to the Holocaust. Albany: State U of New York P, 1997. Print.
3 Dash Moore, Deborah. “Class and Ethnicity in the Creation of New York City Neighborhoods: 1900-1930.” Budapest and New York: Studies in Metropolitan Transformation, 1870-1930. Ed. Thomas Bender and Carl E. Schorske. New York: Russell Sage, 1994. 139-60. Print.
4 Diner, Hasia R. The Jews of the United States, 1654 to 2000. Berkeley: U of California P, 2004. Print.
5 Dinnerstein, Leonard. “Antisemitism in Crisis Times in the United States: The 1920s and 1930s.” Anti-Semitism in Times of Crisis. Ed. Sander L. Gilman and Steven T. Katz. New York: New York UP, 1991. 212-26. Print.
6 Driesen, George B. “Revisiting the Chosen People.” The Reconstructionist 60.2 (1995): 78-84. Print.
7 Dwork, Deborah. “Immigrant Jews on the Lower East Side of New York: 1880-1914.” The American Jewish Experience. Ed. Jonathan D. Sarna. New York: Holmes & Meier, 1986. 102-17. Print.
8 Edmonston, Barry. “Classifying America’s Immigrants: A Review Essay.” Population and Development Review 45.1 (2019): 241-48. Web. 16 Aug. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1111/padr.12243.
9 Efron, John, Matthias Lehmann, and Steven Weitzman. The Jews: A History. New York: Routledge, 2019. Print.
10 Eleff, Zev. “American Orthodoxy’s Lukewarm Embrace of the Hirschian Legacy, 1850-1939.” Tradition: A Journal of Orthodox Jewish Thought 45.3 (2012): 35-53. Print.
11 ---. “‘The Envy of the World and the Pride of the Jews’: Debating the American Jewish University in the Twenties.” Modern Judaism 31.2 (2011): 229-44. Print.
12 ---. “Jewish Immigrants, Liberal Higher Education, and the Quest for a Torah u-Madda Curriculum at Yeshiva College.” Tradition: A Journal of Orthodox Jewish Thought (2011): 19-34. Print.
13 Fishman, Sylvia Barack. The Way into the Varieties of Jewishness. Woodstock, VT: Jewish Lights, 2009. Print.
14 Friedman, Reena Sigman. “The Emergence of Reconstructionism: An Evolving American Judaism, 1922-1945.” American Jewish Archives Journal 48.1 (1996): 1-22. Print.
15 Giddens, Anthony. Sociology. Cambridge: Polity, 2009. Print.
16 Gurock, Jeffrey S. “American Judaism between the Two World Wars.” The Columbia History of Jews and Judaism in America. Ed. Marc Lee Raphael. New York: Columbia UP, 2008. 93-113. Print.
17 ---. “An Orthodox Conspiracy Theory: The Travis Family, Bernard Revel, and the Jewish Theological Seminary.” Modern Judaism 19.3 (1999): 241-53. Print.
18 Gurock, Jeffrey S., and Jacob J. Schacter. A Modern Heretic and a Traditional Community: Mordecai M. Kaplan, Orthodoxy, and American Judaism. New York: Columbia UP, 1997. Print.
19 Healey, Joseph F. Diversity and Society: Race, Ethnicity, and Gender. Los Angeles, CA: Sage, 2010. Print.
20 Hertzberg, Arthur. “In Celebration of the Hundredth Birthday of Mordecai M. Kaplan.” Judaism as a Civilization: Toward a Reconstruction of American-Jewish Life. Ed. Mordecai M. Kaplan. Skokie, IL: Varda, 2001. xxxiii-xlix. Print.
21 Hoenig, Sidney Benjamin. Rabbinics and Research: The Scholarship of Dr. Bernard Revel. New York: Yeshiva UP, 1968. Print.
22 Jacobs, Louis. The Book of Jewish Belief. Springfield, NJ: Behrman House, 1984. Print.
23 Joppke, Christian. Immigration and the Nation-State: The United States, Germany, and Great Britain. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1999. Print.
24 Kaplan, Mordecai M. “A Program for the Reconstruction of Judaism.” The Menorah Journal 6.4 (1920): 181-96. Print.
25 ---. Communings of the Spirit: The Journals of Mordecai M. Kaplan, 1913-1934. Vol. 1. Ed. Mel Scult. Detroit, MI: Wayne State UP, 2001. 3 vols. Print.
26 ---. Judaism as a Civilization: Toward a Reconstruction of American-Jewish Life. Skokie, IL: Varda, 2001. Print.
27 Kaufman, David. Shul with a Pool: The “Synagogue-Center” in American Jewish History. Hanover, NH: Brandeis UP, 1999. Print.
28 Kaufman, Matthew. “The Menorah Journal and Shaping American Jewish Identity: Culture and Evolutionary Sociology.” Shofar 30.4 (2012): 61-79. Print.
29 Langer, Armin. “Educating the Jews to Become Germans: Naftali Herz Homberg’s ‘Civilizing Mission’ to the Jewish Community of Galicia.” Journal for Culture and History of the Germans in Eastern Europe 1.1 (2020): 157-78. Web. 16 Aug. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110671827-010.
30 ---. “Irish Nationalism as an Inspiration for American Zionists in the Early Twentieth Century: As Exemplified by Boston Lawyer Louis D. Brandeis’s Speeches and Writings.” Studi Irlandesi: A Journal of Irish Studies 11 (2021): 323-40. Web. 16 Aug. 2021. https://doi.org/10.13128/SIJIS-2239-3978-12890.
31 ---. Vergeblich integriert? Rabbiner Samson Raphael Hirsch und die jüdische Akkulturation im 19. Jahrhundert. Berlin: Gans, 2019. Print.
32 Lindell, Yosef. “Beacon of Renewal: The Educational Philosophy of the Lida Yeshiva in the Context of Rabbi Isaac Jacob Reines’ Approach to Zionism.” Modern Judaism 29.2 (2009): 268-94. Print.
33 Marcus, Jacob Rader. The Jew in the American World. Detroit, MI: Wayne State UP, 1996. Print.
34 Musher, Deborah Ann. “Reconstructionist Judaism in the Mind of Mordecai Kaplan: The Transformation from a Philosophy into a Religious Denomination.” American Jewish History 86.4 (1998): 397-417. Print.
35 Perlmann, Joel. America Classifies the Immigrants: From Ellis Island to the 2020 Census. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 2018. Print.
36 Revel, Bernard. “Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch: In Honor of the Centenary of His Birth.” The Jewish Exponent 19 June 1908: 1. Print.
37 ---. “Yeshiva College.” Bernard Revel: Builder of American Jewish Orthodoxy. Ed. Aaron Rothkoff. Skokie, IL: Varda, 2001. 255-62. Print.
38 Robinson, Ira. Translating in Tradition: Studies in American Jewish History. Boston, MA: Academic Studies, 2008. Print.
39 Rothkoff, Aaron. Bernard Revel: Builder of American Jewish Orthodoxy. Skokie, IL: Varda, 2001. Print.
40 Ryan, William. Blaming the Victim. New York: Vintage, 1976. Print.
41 Sarna, Jonathan D. American Judaism: A History. New Haven, CT: Yale UP, 2004. Print.
42 ---. “The Cult of Synthesis in American Jewish Culture.” Jewish Social Studies 5.1-2 (1998): 52-79. Print.
43 Satlow, Michael L. Creating Judaism: History, Tradition, Practice. New York: Columbia UP, 2006. Print.
44 Schacter, Jacob J. “Torah u-Madda revisited: The Editor’s Introduction.” The Torah U-Madda Journal 1 (1989): 1-22. Print.
45 Scult, Mel. “Americanism and Judaism in the Thought of Mordecai M. Kaplan.” The Americanization of the Jews. Ed. Robert M. Seltzer and Norman J. Cohen. New York: New York UP, 1995. 339-54. Print.
46 ---. Judaism Faces the Twentieth Century: A Biography of Mordecai M. Kaplan. Detroit, MI: Wayne State UP, 1994. Print.
47 ---. “Mordecai M. Kaplan: Challenges and Conflicts in the Twenties.” American Jewish Historical Quarterly 66.3 (1977): 401-16. Print.
48 ---. The Radical American Judaism of Mordecai M. Kaplan. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 2014. Print.
49 Sherman, Moshe D., and Marc Lee Raphael. Orthodox Judaism in America: A Biographical Dictionary and Sourcebook. Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1996. Print.
50 Silver, Zachary. “The Excommunication of Mordecai Kaplan.” American Jewish Archives Journal 62.1 (2010): 21-48. Print.
51 Stanislawski, Michael. Zionism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2017. Print.
52 Waxman, Chaim I. “Dilemmas of Modern Orthodoxy: Sociological and Philosophical.” Judaism 42.1 (1993): 59-70. Print.
53 Wenger, Beth S. New York Jews and the Great Depression: Uncertain Promise. New Haven, CT: Yale UP, 1996. Print.
54 Zerubavel, Eviatar. Ancestors and Relatives: Genealogy, Identity, and Community. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2012. Print.